force fetch prior to bird exposure?
force fetch prior to bird exposure?
Sorry if this has been covered previously...couldn't find it using the search.
Would anyone advise against force fetching a pup prior to bird exposure? The author of Twentieth Century Bird Dog Training (Er Myron Shelley) advises against it because he said he has seen dogs get so into retrieving they no have no interest in birds. I cannot understand why the force fetch would discourage a bird drive. Any thoughts? There is a limit to the training I can do during the winter. Birds are in the plan for spring time. I definitely could work the force fetch, though.
Appreciate any feedback.
Thank you
Would anyone advise against force fetching a pup prior to bird exposure? The author of Twentieth Century Bird Dog Training (Er Myron Shelley) advises against it because he said he has seen dogs get so into retrieving they no have no interest in birds. I cannot understand why the force fetch would discourage a bird drive. Any thoughts? There is a limit to the training I can do during the winter. Birds are in the plan for spring time. I definitely could work the force fetch, though.
Appreciate any feedback.
Thank you
- gundogguy
- Rank: 5X Champion
- Posts: 980
- Joined: Thu Oct 13, 2011 1:22 pm
- Location: southern Michiganistan
Re: force fetch prior to bird exposure?
I wonder how many dogs he (Myron Shelley) had to FF to come to that opinion? How many have you FF?nritacco wrote:Sorry if this has been covered previously...couldn't find it using the search.
The author of Twentieth Century Bird Dog Training (Er Myron Shelley) advises against it because he said he has seen dogs get so into retrieving they no have no interest in birds. I cannot understand why the force fetch would discourage a bird drive. Any thoughts?
Appreciate any feedback.
Thank you
I'm 100% in favor of LGBT - Liberty, Guns, Bacon and Trump.
- SwitchGrassWPG
- Rank: Champion
- Posts: 356
- Joined: Wed Oct 12, 2005 7:02 pm
- Location: NW Oklahoma
Re: force fetch prior to bird exposure?
Anything that puts pressure on a dog has the potential to affect search or drive. Some dogs fear that pressure and will not venture far from you to prevent the pressure being applied.
I think some additional information about your dog would be beneficial for responses. Breed, age, exposure so far, etc...
I think some additional information about your dog would be beneficial for responses. Breed, age, exposure so far, etc...
Re: force fetch prior to bird exposure?
Before bird introduction? No way. Most people get to bird introduction right away. You get a 8 wk old pup and force fetch it? Force fetch an adult dog. I think retriever's do it by about 6mos but they bring their dog's on faster.
I pity the man that has never been loved by a dog!
Re: force fetch prior to bird exposure?
All the dogs I've trained have always been on birds before ff. During ff I use some frozen birds occasionally, but other than that its minimal birds during early ff. Maybe one a week until I think they have firm grasp on ff, then back to daily.
- gonehuntin'
- GDF Junkie
- Posts: 4870
- Joined: Tue Dec 12, 2006 5:38 pm
- Location: NE WI.
Re: force fetch prior to bird exposure?
It is a common myth that ff increases bird desire in all dogs and certainly, nothing could be further from the truth. In some dogs with only marginal desire to retrieve birds, it can completely kill the desire. Before I ff any dog, especially a pointing dog, I want that dog to be a bird-a-holic. Only then will I ff it. I have my dogs on birds very young though, retrieving and pointing from 8 weeks on if they want to.
LIFE WITHOUT BIRD DOGS AND FLY RODS REALLY ISN'T LIFE AT ALL.
Re: force fetch prior to bird exposure?
Once again, gonehuntin' with gospel - the gospel according to retriever, spaniel and versatile breed trainers all.
MG
MG
Re: force fetch prior to bird exposure?
I would guess that Mr. Shelley FF'd a lot of dogs. Mr. Shelley was a pioneer in dog training. My understanding is that he was the first person to use pigeons in dog training, he was the first person to use johnny houses, or recall funnels.I wonder how many dogs he (Myron Shelley) had to FF to come to that opinion?
The book that the OP is referring to was written in 1921. It is a great book, and was ahead of it's time. I would suggest, however, to the OP to take a look at some of the more modern training books/programs.
- gundogguy
- Rank: 5X Champion
- Posts: 980
- Joined: Thu Oct 13, 2011 1:22 pm
- Location: southern Michiganistan
Re: force fetch prior to bird exposure?
rinker wrote:I would guess that Mr. Shelley FF'd a lot of dogs. Mr. Shelley was a pioneer in dog training. My understanding is that he was the first person to use pigeons in dog training, he was the first person to use johnny houses, or recall funnels.I wonder how many dogs he (Myron Shelley) had to FF to come to that opinion?
The book that the OP is referring to was written in 1921. It is a great book, and was ahead of it's time. I would suggest, however, to the OP to take a look at some of the more modern training books/programs.
In it of it self that's nice to know. FF is not about guess and by gosh. It is about a clear and concise method of explaining to a dog how to be come a problem solver. FF if done correctly, say circa 2015, offers the dog clarity in what is expected. Thousands of dog have been FF over the years, before bird introduction only to go on to become Field Champions and high level shooting dogs.
I'm 100% in favor of LGBT - Liberty, Guns, Bacon and Trump.
-
- Rank: Master Hunter
- Posts: 200
- Joined: Fri Aug 24, 2012 4:38 pm
- Location: Middletown, DE
force fetch prior to bird exposure?
My current dog might have some big time bird issues had I not got him on birds before FF. He was a little unsure at first when we would take walks but more exposure increased his independence factor enormously. I would never go through FF before bird work or recommend to anyone to do FF first.
Re: force fetch prior to bird exposure?
Wow, great feedback, everyone! Thank you very much.
To respond to several of the above questions...this would be the first pup I force fetched. My pup is a 7 months old GSP. I tend to like the Delmar Smith training method, but was curios about the FF after reading Mr. Shelley's book.
Thanks again to everyone for the feedback!
To respond to several of the above questions...this would be the first pup I force fetched. My pup is a 7 months old GSP. I tend to like the Delmar Smith training method, but was curios about the FF after reading Mr. Shelley's book.
Thanks again to everyone for the feedback!
Re: force fetch prior to bird exposure?
[quote="SwitchGrassWPG"]Anything that puts pressure on a dog has the potential to affect search or drive. Some dogs fear that pressure and will not venture far from you to prevent the pressure being applied. ............................................
quote]
Exactly.
quote]
Exactly.
" We are more than our gender, skin color, class, sexuality or age; we are unlimited potential, and can not be defined by one label." quote A. Bartlett
Re: force fetch prior to bird exposure?
I currently have a lab that this applies to, would only go out about 10 yards and then come back. It took a week of daily planted birds to fix it. All dogs react differently to ff.SwitchGrassWPG wrote:Anything that puts pressure on a dog has the potential to affect search or drive. Some dogs fear that pressure and will not venture far from you to prevent the pressure being applied.
Re: force fetch prior to bird exposure?
If your dog is 7 months old and has not been exposed to birds yet, then in my opinion you are failing as a new trainer. Get the dog on birds and build desire. That would be my focus before Force Fetch.nritacco wrote:Wow, great feedback, everyone! Thank you very much.
To respond to several of the above questions...this would be the first pup I force fetched. My pup is a 7 months old GSP. I tend to like the Delmar Smith training method, but was curios about the FF after reading Mr. Shelley's book.
Thanks again to everyone for the feedback!
Re: force fetch prior to bird exposure?
I have had a couple of GWPs come to me for Bird work and steadiness that were FFed before they came to me. Both dogs did well and looked good doing the work. But they were Professionally FFed and the degree of pressure is different dog to dog and trainer to trainer. Some dogs can do it and others can`t. First time FFing I would not recommend it. It is going to be a big learning experience for you and the dog and mistakes are going to be made. My own personal feelings on all this is, I want all the work before the shot done to expectations before moving on to the work after the shot. If the work before the shot is not complete what is there to retrieve?
Re: force fetch prior to bird exposure?
If your dog is 7 months old and has not been exposed to birds yet, then in my opinion you are failing as a new trainer. Get the dog on birds and build desire. That would be my focus before Force Fetch.
Friend, this is a hobby. I'm having fun with my dog. I have a full time job and a full time family. Not everyone has the resources to train like a pro.
I'm only failing if my pup and I don't have fun, and if we don't learn from our time working together. Thanks for your input.
-
- Rank: 5X Champion
- Posts: 1271
- Joined: Sun Jun 22, 2014 5:10 pm
- Location: Northern Minnesota
Re: force fetch prior to bird exposure?
nritacco wrote:If your dog is 7 months old and has not been exposed to birds yet, then in my opinion you are failing as a new trainer. Get the dog on birds and build desire. That would be my focus before Force Fetch.
Amen! I love training and I love my dog... But life is busy so my training schedule coincidentally lines up with my free time. Weird.
Friend, this is a hobby. I'm having fun with my dog. I have a full time job and a full time family. Not everyone has the resources to train like a pro.
I'm only failing if my pup and I don't have fun, and if we don't learn from our time working together. Thanks for your input.
“Man's mind, once stretched by a new idea, never regains its original dimensions.”
― Oliver Wendell Holmes Sr.
― Oliver Wendell Holmes Sr.
- gonehuntin'
- GDF Junkie
- Posts: 4870
- Joined: Tue Dec 12, 2006 5:38 pm
- Location: NE WI.
Re: force fetch prior to bird exposure?
You have TIME to worry about this. When I was a trainer, MANY of the dog's that came into me were 1 1/2- 2 years old. There's only so many hours in a day. Get him birdy first, worry about the training later. The most important things you can do with that pup is to develop independence by letting him run on long walks, use mild correction when he disobeys in the house, like NO, so he gets used to being corrected and expose him to birds. The rest will come in time.
LIFE WITHOUT BIRD DOGS AND FLY RODS REALLY ISN'T LIFE AT ALL.