crackerd wrote:Don't think you want to be a wise*ss - there are retriever programs to follow,yes, there aren't spaniel programs unless you tell us otherwise. Perfect has nothing to do with them, perseverance and following sequentially does.
MG
Now Now Crackerd There is NO perfect spaniel program and I will begin to explain. However there is a perfect nonslip retriever program to follow. It is all in the geometry of the game.
I concur with general premise of that the non-slip retriever trial is based on long distant precision obedience which the E-collar made possible with the training experimentation and set-up development of such luminaries as Rex Carr. Back in the 1960’s retrievers in this country were working at distances in trial that would barely get you qualifying score in today’s world of Hunt Tests. As you know with advent of the e-collar, distance both in marking and in blind work has gone into the stratosphere, 500 yrds being quite common place in many trial training camps, marks and blind. In Fenwick or Onaway Michigan even greater distances are being achieved. Technical lands dedicated to the development of the non-slip retriever.
However flushing spaniel (Cocker Or Springer) trials are NOT obedience events. The elements of trial revolve around standards that have been in place quite some time. They are judge subjectively based those standards. The distances that dogs work at are more dictated by the improvement in gunning over dogs in the field. Even with modern ammo and guns tweeked to the max, marking distances are still limited to proper gunning distances. Yes, the e-collar is used in the development of spaniels preparing for trial. Back in ED W days one could go to a 30 dog trial for example and 10-12 dogs would be drop from contention for breaking at flush and shot, today maybe 1-2 dogs would break, obedience has improved dramatically in the last 25-30yrs though there is still only one winner, and from my vantage point that usually the most stylish bird finder and spot on marker.
( As an aside I' really concerned about the amount of handling I see in Cocker trials on marked retrieves both here and in the UK).
Back to the discussion Running style can be affected by the e-collar in certain spaniel blood lines. Flushing strength or boldness can also be affected. Even the overall attractiveness that the animated spaniel possesses can be affected.
For the pet hunter companion those issue may hold no importance, however for the trialer and some extent the hunt tester they may be difference in continuing with the dog or replacing the dog.
The spaniel blood lines have not been tested, pressurized and monitored the way the retriever blood lines have and how they handle force and pressure, for the last 40 yrs. Non-slip retriever training is a formulated process of canine behavior modification. The rules of development of the questing flushing spaniel, well 2+2 does not always equal 4
Questing spaniels compared to Non slip retrievers is like comparing apples to a Hersey chocolate bar, they are both sweet and tasty but they are different.
There is much that could be discussed.
HS
I really donot think jhorak was trying start anything with his cautionary tale, I think possible he was just speaking for experience which I could relate to quite easily!
I'm 100% in favor of LGBT - Liberty, Guns, Bacon and Trump.