E Collar or Garmin

Post Reply
woodedareas

E Collar or Garmin

Post by woodedareas » Wed Aug 12, 2009 2:23 pm

I am about to bu a TriTronics E collar but have become interested in the Gamin GPS collar. I realize that with Garmin I can track my dog and with the ecollar I can stimulate the dog.My dog is young and just beginning hunting. He will be trained enough with basic commands to use an ecollar soon. I like the Garmin as I can track the dog for a considerable diatance plus also know where I am and how to get back to the truck.What are you using and any advice?

User avatar
MTO4Life
Rank: Champion
Posts: 323
Joined: Wed Jul 02, 2008 12:10 pm
Location: Guelph, Ontario, Canada

Re: E Collar or Garmin

Post by MTO4Life » Wed Aug 12, 2009 3:30 pm

I'm by no means a pro here, but I use both. The Garmin is great, lets me see what my dog is doing, but if I command here, and the Garmin tells me she is still hauling a%* away from me, I can nick her with the e-collar and fix that problem right there. Without the e-collar, the Garmin shows me she is still running away!! Maybe others have opinions on this, but that isw my $0.02 worth. It is expensive to get both, but I rationalized that it was cheaper than the vet bills from my dog getting hurt or hit, or replacing the dog!

User avatar
natetnc
Rank: 5X Champion
Posts: 714
Joined: Mon Jun 18, 2007 5:59 pm

Re: E Collar or Garmin

Post by natetnc » Wed Aug 12, 2009 4:33 pm

e-collar first, run it with a beeper if you want a little piece of mind. garmin is nice, i would suggest it to anyone...... but not over an e-collar, that is if you plan to train with an e-collar, i assume you are since you mentioned it.

User avatar
kninebirddog
GDF Premier Member!
Posts: 7846
Joined: Sat Dec 25, 2004 12:45 am
Location: Coolidge AZ

Re: E Collar or Garmin

Post by kninebirddog » Wed Aug 12, 2009 5:04 pm

yep for me e collar comes first...I do not need a dog that learns to hunt for themselves and then have to track them down to find them
the e collar specially now a days is the most humane way to teach that provided you follow a method and teach the dog

both have their place but i like to be able to maintain my dogs training not just chase them down with a garmin
"I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all."
"When I hear somebody talk about a horse or cow being stupid, I figure its a sure sign that the animal has outfoxed them." Tom Dorrance
If you feel like you are banging your head against the wall, try using the door.

User avatar
gonehuntin'
GDF Junkie
Posts: 4867
Joined: Tue Dec 12, 2006 5:38 pm
Location: NE WI.

Re: E Collar or Garmin

Post by gonehuntin' » Wed Aug 12, 2009 7:25 pm

I would always opt for the ecollar over the Astro. That being said, I run them with both on. It's the way to go. That is as safe as you can possibly make it for a dog.
LIFE WITHOUT BIRD DOGS AND FLY RODS REALLY ISN'T LIFE AT ALL.

User avatar
bossman
Rank: 5X Champion
Posts: 755
Joined: Thu Mar 12, 2009 9:14 pm
Location: McKinney, Tx

Re: E Collar or Garmin

Post by bossman » Wed Aug 12, 2009 8:49 pm

I RUN MY DOGS WITH BOTH..iF YOU NEED TO GET JUST ONE...E COLLAR WITH BEEPER.

User avatar
DGFavor
GDF Junkie
Posts: 1949
Joined: Fri Feb 24, 2006 1:55 am
Location: Pocatello, ID

Re: E Collar or Garmin

Post by DGFavor » Thu Aug 13, 2009 12:05 am

No brainer - if I could only have one, the tracking collar. I'd gladly turn my dogs loose without an e-collar no matter their level of training or my training goals with them but never, never without a tracking collar on. If I know where they're at and what they're doin', I can still work or train 'em without an e-collar. If I don't know where they're at or what they're up to, the e-collar is useless. :wink:

Reality is...I usually have e-collar, telemetry collar,and Garmin collar on dog! :oops: :lol: But if I could only use one, I'd opt for some sort of tracking device.

RayGubernat
GDF Junkie
Posts: 3307
Joined: Fri Jun 20, 2008 11:47 am
Location: Central DE

Re: E Collar or Garmin

Post by RayGubernat » Thu Aug 13, 2009 10:42 am

Doc Favor has it right I think.

If you cannot see your dog or do not knw what it is doing, you should not use the e-collar.

For many hunters and e-collar and a beeper, either separate or as a combo unit, makes a lot of sense. Especially if the beeper has a "point" mode.

For those of us who routinely expect our dogs to be out of sight, a tracking device of some sort is really the first order of business. If you know where the dog is and what it is doing(moving versus standing still) you can use the e-collar to reinforce the come command. If the dog is standing still, you can go there and get the dog.

RayG

User avatar
BDBUzi
Rank: Junior Hunter
Posts: 61
Joined: Tue Aug 26, 2008 9:05 am

Re: E Collar or Garmin

Post by BDBUzi » Thu Aug 13, 2009 11:38 am

I agree with Doug and Ray.
The ecollar isn't going to do you any good if the dog is tangled up in barbed wire or fallen of a ledge over the hill from you.

As mentioned before, a combination of the two is the ultimate setup.

Dave Quindt
Rank: 5X Champion
Posts: 876
Joined: Tue Jul 05, 2005 8:22 pm

Re: E Collar or Garmin

Post by Dave Quindt » Thu Aug 13, 2009 1:47 pm

For the training of foot-handled hunting dogs, I'd start with an e-collar. Having all of the options is certainly nice, but not necessary and for the newbie without a lot of experience, having to manage them all can be counterproductive.

A tracker is pretty useless for the guy training a basic hunting dog off of foot; a tracker becomes useful at ranges that exceed what 99% of the non-trialing hunters will ever see in training. In a vast majority of the country if you're training a dog off of foot, if the dog is at a range where the tracker is useful you're screwed anyway, because the dog is moving faster than you'll ever be able to keep up with. The Garmin is slightly more useful in that it quantifies how far the dog is from you, and you can recognize when it's time to stop chasing the dog, get back to your truck, and try to gain some ground on the dog.

In my experience, 95% of the pros training hunting dogs from foot in open cover are running nothing but an e-collar. It's really the best option, as it forces you maintain contact with the dog, and vise versa. Add a bell or beeper to help you as an amateur trainer and you'll be fine. When dealing with heavier cover, give me an e-collar with a quality bell (not the cheap ones from the local sporting goods store) and a beeper on point-only and I got everything I'd need.

Basic training for a birddog is nothing more than some general obedience, very basic patterning work and steadying the dog on birds. All of that's accomplished with the dog less than 100 yards from you. If you need a tracker or Garmin to accomplish that, you're doing something wrong.

If you're like a lot of guys on this site, and this thread, and you're developing a dog with trial-potential or you run off of horseback or wheeler or you live in parts of the west where you can let a hunting dog roll in training and still maintain contact, trackers and Garmins will be helpful. Since you, like I, live in Illinois and you've mentioned that you have a DeCoverly Setter I assume you are looking for a casual hunting dog.

JMO,
Dave

User avatar
gonehuntin'
GDF Junkie
Posts: 4867
Joined: Tue Dec 12, 2006 5:38 pm
Location: NE WI.

Re: E Collar or Garmin

Post by gonehuntin' » Thu Aug 13, 2009 8:36 pm

Dave Quindt wrote: A tracker is pretty useless for the guy training a basic hunting dog off of foot; a tracker becomes useful at ranges that exceed what 99% of the non-trialing hunters will ever see in training.
JMO,
Dave
Anyone that hunts grouse in the north and pheasant in the Dakotas can use and needs a tracker. I like them because the birds don't run out from the point like they will a bell or beeper. When a dog's working 100-150 yards out in a thick grouse woods, they're mighty hard to find. The Astro makes that a snap.

Same in the Dakotas in heavy CRP. Most hunting dogs work to about 100 yards and you'll have a heck of a time finding that dog in the CRP when he's more than 30 yards. out. Even the worst slug works over 30 yards.

That's how I use them Dave, for silence on the birds.
LIFE WITHOUT BIRD DOGS AND FLY RODS REALLY ISN'T LIFE AT ALL.

Dave Quindt
Rank: 5X Champion
Posts: 876
Joined: Tue Jul 05, 2005 8:22 pm

Re: E Collar or Garmin

Post by Dave Quindt » Thu Aug 13, 2009 9:42 pm

Anyone that hunts grouse in the north and pheasant in the Dakotas can use and needs a tracker. I like them because the birds don't run out from the point like they will a bell or beeper. When a dog's working 100-150 yards out in a thick grouse woods, they're mighty hard to find. The Astro makes that a snap.

Same in the Dakotas in heavy CRP. Most hunting dogs work to about 100 yards and you'll have a heck of a time finding that dog in the CRP when he's more than 30 yards. out. Even the worst slug works over 30 yards.

That's how I use them Dave, for silence on the birds.
That's all fine and dandy, but that's hunting and not training. There's certainly a place for trackers in hunting, but the original poster is a newbie to training and is looking for what technology can best help him train his dog. If he can't get his dog at least staunch, if not broke, he won't have much opportunity to find his dog buried in cover with a tracker or Garmin, will he now?

Neil
GDF Junkie
Posts: 3187
Joined: Mon Jun 29, 2009 12:46 pm
Location: Central Arkansas

Re: E Collar or Garmin

Post by Neil » Fri Aug 14, 2009 3:09 am

The reason it is not easy to answer this false choice question is that most of us have trained a lot of dogs without any electronics, so we know it can be done, and be done well.

I use both an e-collar and Garmin on every pointing dog I turn loose, everyone - every time!

Now, if the batteries are down or the unit defective, there are some dogs I will not run without a tracking device, I would just leave them in the truck and not risk it. That is not true with the e-collar, if it is not working I will still run the dogs. So perhaps that tells which is the most important to me.

It is a common misunderstanding that the tracking devices is only for the big running All-Age type dog, due to their independence, and practice at finding their way back to the front, it is rarely really needed for them. But the close hunting, dependent dog, that stays in sight, does not want to get far from you, is the one I fear will be lost and not recovered. They panic when they lose contact and don't know what to do. The big running dog does not even know or care.

You see big running dogs must have both an internal compass and timer, added to acute hearing or they could not run so big without being lost every time. I think that is what separates them, it is not desire, for I have seen close hunting dogs that have all the drive to find birds as the current NC, they just do not have the confidence to be out of sight doing it.

To honestly answer the question, if money were tight, I would not buy either, I would spend more money and time training and hunting the dog.

Neil

User avatar
gonehuntin'
GDF Junkie
Posts: 4867
Joined: Tue Dec 12, 2006 5:38 pm
Location: NE WI.

Re: E Collar or Garmin

Post by gonehuntin' » Fri Aug 14, 2009 5:25 am

Dave Quindt wrote: That's all fine and dandy, but that's hunting and not training. There's certainly a place for trackers in hunting, but the original poster is a newbie to training and is looking for what technology can best help him train his dog. If he can't get his dog at least staunch, if not broke, he won't have much opportunity to find his dog buried in cover with a tracker or Garmin, will he now?
I don't know of any person, anywhere, that considers a tracker, a training aid. I think most of us, if not all, thought he was asking the conjunction with regard to both training and hunting. Dogs have been trained since man started training them without an electric collar, but it's sure nice to be able to find them in heavy cover.

Nope, if he can't get his dog staunch, he won't shot many birds over him, but on the other hand, if the dog is staunch and he can't find him, that won't do him much good either, will it now?
LIFE WITHOUT BIRD DOGS AND FLY RODS REALLY ISN'T LIFE AT ALL.

woodedareas

Re: E Collar or Garmin

Post by woodedareas » Sat Aug 15, 2009 8:07 am

I appreciate the excellent responses to my question.It is unfortunate that someone has not produced a simple e collar that includesa garmin type gps all in one. I guess this raises one more question if you use an ecollar , do you then add an additional collar for the Garmin or GPS device. Seems like a lot of electronics to hang on one dogs neck. Based on my research I recall that the Garmin has a beeper that is included. In this respect there would be 2 electronic devices on one or two collars, one for the Garmin andf one for the ecollar. Or am I way off base?
Thanks
Allen

User avatar
Mike50
Rank: Master Hunter
Posts: 228
Joined: Tue Feb 13, 2007 3:51 pm
Location: Wisconsin

Re: E Collar or Garmin

Post by Mike50 » Sat Aug 15, 2009 9:15 am

woodedareas wrote:I appreciate the excellent responses to my question.It is unfortunate that someone has not produced a simple e collar that includesa garmin type gps all in one. I guess this raises one more question if you use an ecollar , do you then add an additional collar for the Garmin or GPS device. Seems like a lot of electronics to hang on one dogs neck. Based on my research I recall that the Garmin has a beeper that is included. In this respect there would be 2 electronic devices on one or two collars, one for the Garmin andf one for the ecollar. Or am I way off base?
Thanks
Allen
I don't think we'll ever see a all in one collar Ecollar GPS. Their two separate devices that both require a power source. Each has their place and function. To get a smaller ecollar you now sacrifice range. How big would the transmitter for the ecollar and receiver for the GPS have to be? I wouldn't buy one. I can hunt with out one. But hunt with out both when it breaks down?

User avatar
DGFavor
GDF Junkie
Posts: 1949
Joined: Fri Feb 24, 2006 1:55 am
Location: Pocatello, ID

Re: E Collar or Garmin

Post by DGFavor » Sat Aug 15, 2009 11:05 am

I don't know of any person, anywhere, that considers a tracker, a training aid.
You're in luck! You do now! They are great training aids - like I said before, if I know where the dog is at and what it is doing, I can work with 'em. We just train soley on native game so we really can't plan to work on backing, retrieving, STF, bird manners, etc because we might just get skunked that day. What we can work on every time out is dogs hunting to the front and with telemetry or Garmin, we can tell quickly when a dog is getting wayward then start working on getting 'em back to the front - whether that be by call/whistle, putting the profile of our horse so the dog can see where we're headed, e-collar or running 'em down and showing 'em the front. If we don't know where they're at, makes it really hard to work on that pattern...and honestly, wayward hunting patterns is where a large majority of dogs come up short at field trials and is a great way to lose your dog out hunting. Wayward dogs open up 360 degrees of possible places to get lost, typically front running dogs can at least give you some confidence to eliminate 180 degrees of places to go look for 'em.

Yesterday, we turned two dogs loose from the trailer, each wearing an e-collar and telemetry. After about 3 minutes, another of my dogs, Bugsy, came streaking past, apparently escaping his dog box. One of the dogs we were working was doing a nice job, staying well within the limits of the country, not a threat to get lost. Robbed his tele collar and put it on Bugs - found Bugs over the hill on sharpies short time later, worked the shorter ranging youngster in on the find and bird work for all!! :lol:

User avatar
ACooper
GDF Premier Member!
Posts: 3397
Joined: Tue Nov 23, 2004 1:37 pm
Location: Sometimes I'm in Oklahoma

Re: E Collar or Garmin

Post by ACooper » Sat Aug 15, 2009 12:37 pm

Mike50 wrote:
woodedareas wrote:I appreciate the excellent responses to my question.It is unfortunate that someone has not produced a simple e collar that includesa garmin type gps all in one. I guess this raises one more question if you use an ecollar , do you then add an additional collar for the Garmin or GPS device. Seems like a lot of electronics to hang on one dogs neck. Based on my research I recall that the Garmin has a beeper that is included. In this respect there would be 2 electronic devices on one or two collars, one for the Garmin andf one for the ecollar. Or am I way off base?
Thanks
Allen
I don't think we'll ever see a all in one collar Ecollar GPS. Their two separate devices that both require a power source. Each has their place and function. To get a smaller ecollar you now sacrifice range. How big would the transmitter for the ecollar and receiver for the GPS have to be? I wouldn't buy one. I can hunt with out one. But hunt with out both when it breaks down?

I disagree I think we will see a combo in the near future, I would bet there are people who have their own combo going now with a little ingenuity. We have a beeper/ecoolar combo, the gps/ecollar combo is a no brainer.

User avatar
Mike50
Rank: Master Hunter
Posts: 228
Joined: Tue Feb 13, 2007 3:51 pm
Location: Wisconsin

Re: E Collar or Garmin

Post by Mike50 » Sat Aug 15, 2009 2:55 pm

For those of you running a GPS collar unit. What is the battery life on one charge till you no longer receive a signal telling you were your dog is. My hand held GPS is good for about 6 hrs if I don't play with it. That's with lithium batteries in it.

User avatar
glk7243
Rank: Senior Hunter
Posts: 148
Joined: Sun May 28, 2006 9:58 am

Re: E Collar or Garmin

Post by glk7243 » Sat Aug 15, 2009 4:18 pm

I think the manual says 18 hrs. I have 2 and have used them a lot and I would say that is close. You get a signal on your handheld that tells you it is really low before it goes dead. The handheld, simliar to a 60csx last much longer than the 6hrs you are getting. Mine lasts a lot longer (with duracells) than the collar charge.
Regards
Gary

User avatar
gonehuntin'
GDF Junkie
Posts: 4867
Joined: Tue Dec 12, 2006 5:38 pm
Location: NE WI.

Re: E Collar or Garmin

Post by gonehuntin' » Sat Aug 15, 2009 4:35 pm

DGFavor wrote:
I don't know of any person, anywhere, that considers a tracker, a training aid.
You're in luck! You do now! They are great training aids - like I said before, if I know where the dog is at and what it is doing, I can work with 'em. We just train soley on native game so we really can't plan to work on backing, retrieving, STF, bird manners, etc because we might just get skunked that day. What we can work on every time out is dogs hunting to the front and with telemetry or Garmin, we can tell quickly when a dog is getting wayward then start working on getting 'em back to the front - whether that be by call/whistle, putting the profile of our horse so the dog can see where we're headed, e-collar or running 'em down and showing 'em the front. If we don't know where they're at, makes it really hard to work on that pattern...and honestly, wayward hunting patterns is where a large majority of dogs come up short at field trials and is a great way to lose your dog out hunting. Wayward dogs open up 360 degrees of possible places to get lost, typically front running dogs can at least give you some confidence to eliminate 180 degrees of places to go look for 'em.

Yesterday, we turned two dogs loose from the trailer, each wearing an e-collar and telemetry. After about 3 minutes, another of my dogs, Bugsy, came streaking past, apparently escaping his dog box. One of the dogs we were working was doing a nice job, staying well within the limits of the country, not a threat to get lost. Robbed his tele collar and put it on Bugs - found Bugs over the hill on sharpies short time later, worked the shorter ranging youngster in on the find and bird work for all!! :lol:

To me, that would all still be location, not training. Once you find the dog, the training starts.
LIFE WITHOUT BIRD DOGS AND FLY RODS REALLY ISN'T LIFE AT ALL.

Dave Quindt
Rank: 5X Champion
Posts: 876
Joined: Tue Jul 05, 2005 8:22 pm

Re: E Collar or Garmin

Post by Dave Quindt » Sat Aug 15, 2009 7:52 pm

Mike50 wrote:For those of you running a GPS collar unit. What is the battery life on one charge till you no longer receive a signal telling you were your dog is. My hand held GPS is good for about 6 hrs if I don't play with it. That's with lithium batteries in it.
Are you sure you've got the battery type set for Lithium?

I too get close to 18 hours out of a set of Lithiums. You can also "hot swap" batteries by plugging the unit into a 12 volt outlet using the mini-usb jack. You can then replace the batteries and unplug from the 12v power and the unit will keep tracking the entire time. I tried it last year when I was too lazy to go hunt in the rain and was stuck in the truck.

I'm guessing you could probably do the same thing with one of the portable emergency battery packs that you can use to charge a cell phone with, but have not tried that.

FWIW,
Dave

lvrgsp
GDF Junkie
Posts: 2511
Joined: Sat Jun 10, 2006 9:12 am
Location: ILLA NOISE..................

Re: E Collar or Garmin

Post by lvrgsp » Sun Aug 16, 2009 9:26 am

ACooper wrote:
Mike50 wrote:
woodedareas wrote:I appreciate the excellent responses to my question.It is unfortunate that someone has not produced a simple e collar that includesa garmin type gps all in one. I guess this raises one more question if you use an ecollar , do you then add an additional collar for the Garmin or GPS device. Seems like a lot of electronics to hang on one dogs neck. Based on my research I recall that the Garmin has a beeper that is included. In this respect there would be 2 electronic devices on one or two collars, one for the Garmin andf one for the ecollar. Or am I way off base?
Thanks
Allen
I don't think we'll ever see a all in one collar Ecollar GPS. Their two separate devices that both require a power source. Each has their place and function. To get a smaller ecollar you now sacrifice range. How big would the transmitter for the ecollar and receiver for the GPS have to be? I wouldn't buy one. I can hunt with out one. But hunt with out both when it breaks down?

I disagree I think we will see a combo in the near future, I would bet there are people who have their own combo going now with a little ingenuity. We have a beeper/ecoolar combo, the gps/ecollar combo is a no brainer.

Pretty sure TT is working on one now, may be awhile for the final product, but I hear it's in the works......

FWIW,
Chip

Dave Quindt
Rank: 5X Champion
Posts: 876
Joined: Tue Jul 05, 2005 8:22 pm

Re: E Collar or Garmin

Post by Dave Quindt » Sun Aug 16, 2009 10:49 am

The beeper/e-collar combo is really two separate units with two separate power supplies, at least the TT product. The only way the two interact is the signal being sent from the collar to turn the beeper on or off.

The problem with a GPS-ecollar combo is going to be the power requirements of the two units. If both draw from one power supply can it be small enough to be usable? The other issue will be whether or not you can use the GPS without the e-collar, for use in competition. If you can't, that will limit the potential market.

A GPS tracker was a logical product for Garmin, as they are in the GPS business. For TT to develop a GPS collar they need to get into technology and applications they have never dealt with before. All for a pretty niche market.

I think it's going to be longer than we think.

JMO,
Dave

User avatar
ACooper
GDF Premier Member!
Posts: 3397
Joined: Tue Nov 23, 2004 1:37 pm
Location: Sometimes I'm in Oklahoma

Re: E Collar or Garmin

Post by ACooper » Sun Aug 16, 2009 12:54 pm

Dave Quindt wrote:
The problem with a GPS-ecollar combo is going to be the power requirements of the two units. If both draw from one power supply can it be small enough to be usable? The other issue will be whether or not you can use the GPS without the e-collar, for use in competition. If you can't, that will limit the potential market.

It will only slightly limit the market, non trialers are the ones keeping the TT, sportdog etc in business. I guess it depends on the demand, if the demand is there garmin, tt, sportdog, or someone will find a way to get it done, but like you said it may be later rather than sooner.

User avatar
Mike50
Rank: Master Hunter
Posts: 228
Joined: Tue Feb 13, 2007 3:51 pm
Location: Wisconsin

Re: E Collar or Garmin

Post by Mike50 » Sun Aug 16, 2009 2:08 pm

Dave Quindt wrote:
Mike50 wrote:For those of you running a GPS collar unit. What is the battery life on one charge till you no longer receive a signal telling you were your dog is. My hand held GPS is good for about 6 hrs if I don't play with it. That's with lithium batteries in it.
Are you sure you've got the battery type set for Lithium?

I too get close to 18 hours out of a set of Lithiums. You can also "hot swap" batteries by plugging the unit into a 12 volt outlet using the mini-usb jack. You can then replace the batteries and unplug from the 12v power and the unit will keep tracking the entire time. I tried it last year when I was too lazy to go hunt in the rain and was stuck in the truck.

I'm guessing you could probably do the same thing with one of the portable emergency battery packs that you can use to charge a cell phone with, but have not tried that.

FWIW,
Dave
Sorry didn't mean to mislead you. The GPS I have is a lowrance color unit to help me get unlost when I do. Not a gamin tracking collar combo

User avatar
Mike50
Rank: Master Hunter
Posts: 228
Joined: Tue Feb 13, 2007 3:51 pm
Location: Wisconsin

Re: E Collar or Garmin

Post by Mike50 » Sun Aug 16, 2009 2:18 pm

I think if they ever do come out with a all in one combo. It will most likely weight about the same as 2 units do now. Minus the weight of one collar. And since the neck muscle is one of if not the biggest muscles on a dog. Buy both and strap them on.

Post Reply