Garmin vs. Tracker - tracking collars

[Retiredbirddogman]

Any strong opinions one way or the other on Garmin vs. Tracker tracking collars?
Thanks.

[gonehuntin']

I run gps chips in my Garmin. Whenever that unit is on and tracking, I can see on a topographical map EXACTLY where I and the dog are. That, to me, is invaluable. Can't do that with the Tracker.

I also don't like the Trackers method of switching stimulation on the dog.

As far as I can see, the Tracker is not a lot different than running the dog with a beeper.

[Sue]

LOVE my Garmin. Haven't tried the other...

[Ricky Ticky Shorthairs]

It depends what you are using it for. For hunting the Garmin is great. For field trails, I'd use a tracker. The tracker has a lot longer batery life. I've seen quite a few people lose dogs at field trials, and pull out the Garmin, and not get any signal at all.

Sounds like the new Garmin offers more range via a longer antanna. New screens and software look pretty cool.

Doug

[Ricky Ticky Shorthairs]

gonehuntin' wrote

I also don't like the Trackers method of switching stimulation on the dog.

As far as I can see, the Tracker is not a lot different than running the dog with a beeper

Trackers don't offer stimulation.

A tracker is a lot different than a beeper. You're not gonna hear that beeper much past 200 yards. I have found dogs at 1 to 2 miles with a tracker. Trackers only make noise at the remote, not on the dog. Much easier to go stealth.

Doug

[Retiredbirddogman]

Thanks for the input.

[birddog1968]

The reason the garmin won't pick up when asked for at the trial is because its not being used as designed.

The Garmin was not meant to be turned off then turned on like is asked at trails. If you turn it on, acquire the collars then leave it on there is no problem. The problem lies when judges or the folks who wrote the rules didn't understand how the system is supposed to work.

[azwoodsman]

I don't know much about the tracker but I do own a 320 astro and I love it. one of the neat things is getting back from a hunt and downloading you and your dog's tracks on base camp you can see how your dog hunted and what area's he covered lots of other neat stuff on the hand held I have not had a problem with mine.

[jimbo&rooster]

I use both. I use the garmin, more for data collection, when hunning dogs ( how far and what are they doing) If i truely have a dog lost I would rather have my tracker on them. I havn;t used my garmin enough to really have a good feel for how it works. Out of state hunting or trialing a dog I would go to my tracker first.

Jim

[cjuve]

For the majority of people an Astro is the way to go, to find a truly lost dog I would take a tracker hands down. The newer long range antenna works well on the Astro and you can pick up dogs quite a ways out. If you are a hunter and your dogs range moderately in open country you should have no issues, broken country with big running dogs the tracker comes in handy but does not have all the neat features. Bottom line if a big runner gets away in my country you will wish you had a tracker.

[Neil]

Since they both use Rf, the difference in range is the antenna, you can buy a long range garmin antenna that some report 20+ miles.

[coveydogs]

For the majority of people an Astro is the way to go, to find a truly lost dog I would take a tracker hands down. The newer long range antenna works well on the Astro and you can pick up dogs quite a ways out. If you are a hunter and your dogs range moderately in open country you should have no issues, broken country with big running dogs the tracker comes in handy but does not have all the neat features. Bottom line if a big runner gets away in my country you will wish you had a tracker.

Yep! Plus the trackers have a battery life of 500 hours... you lose a dog overnight with a garmin on dont expect the unit to have power enough to search much the next day (17 hour battery life on highest refresh rate and a full battery). Lost dog you want a tracker, all the cool features make you want a garmin.

Since they both use Rf, the difference in range is the antenna, you can buy a long range garmin antenna that some report 20+ miles.

There is still a difference, even if the signal is not strong enough to hear the beep, the tracker will make a tiny click for you to know what direction to go; that same weak signal might not be something the garmin could translate into a direction for you.

All that being said I have a garmin, my pups check back in pretty well and only one ranges to the ends of the earth. Depends on what you want, how you hunt, where you hunt, how big your dogs run etc etc.