To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
My Brit now just plain refuses to retrieve anything. As a pup he would and through his first full year of hunting. He started getting selective when he would retrieve after the first year. I only hunted a few times his second season because of an illness I had that year. He always finds the downed bird but will either stand beside it (if it's dead) or lay down with his legs on it (if it's alive). If someone I am hunting with goes to pick up the bird he will snatch it and bring it to me. He'll be 5 in December, I've never force fetch trained a dog and not really sure if it's the right thing to do. So any advice?
http://www.perfectpedigrees.com/genview.php?id=3600
"I think we are drawn to dogs because they are the uninhibited creatures we might be if we weren't certain we knew better." -George Bird Evans " Troubles with Bird Dogs"
"I think we are drawn to dogs because they are the uninhibited creatures we might be if we weren't certain we knew better." -George Bird Evans " Troubles with Bird Dogs"
- gonehuntin'
- GDF Junkie
- Posts: 4870
- Joined: Tue Dec 12, 2006 5:38 pm
- Location: NE WI.
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
Sounds to me like the dog is a natural retriever and just calling your bluff. If it were me that would be an affront to me and I'd ff the dog. Which is why I don't take chances and ff them all from day one anyhow.
LIFE WITHOUT BIRD DOGS AND FLY RODS REALLY ISN'T LIFE AT ALL.
- Dakotazeb
- Rank: 4X Champion
- Posts: 671
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2014 1:10 pm
- Location: South Dakota / Arizona
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
I'd FF that dog in a heart beat. Nothing worse than a dog that refuses to retrieve. But if you never have done it yourself I would spend the money and have professional do it. Cost will probably be about $600-700 but in the end it will be worth every penny. I've had Brittanys for 20 years and have paid to have a couple FF'd. I tried it myself but found it difficult when I got to the "force" portion of the training.
Janee's August Breeze - Bree
http://gundogcentral.com/view_pedigree. ... erations=5
NSTRA Champion Godfather's Dakota Elle 2008-2016
https://gundogcentral.com/view_pedigree ... erations=5
http://gundogcentral.com/view_pedigree. ... erations=5
NSTRA Champion Godfather's Dakota Elle 2008-2016
https://gundogcentral.com/view_pedigree ... erations=5
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
how much is it bothering you? Only you can decide if you'd try fixing it, after considering the cost and the risks.
If you do it yourself, you can screw your relationship with the dog forever, esp 5 yo.
Someone you pay to do it can screw it up too. So it'd be important to find a trainer you trust.
Greatest debates of our times....
I'd use jealousy to train fetch - another dog or a person, as you describe.
If you do it yourself, you can screw your relationship with the dog forever, esp 5 yo.
Someone you pay to do it can screw it up too. So it'd be important to find a trainer you trust.
Greatest debates of our times....
I'd use jealousy to train fetch - another dog or a person, as you describe.
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
As I don't train force fetch the above would be the first thing I'd try too. If it did not work then I'd either try F.F. or C.T. and I'd try C.T. first of those two as there is less that can go badly wrong when done by an inexperienced trainer.h&t wrote: I'd use jealousy to train fetch - another dog or a person, as you describe.
Bill T.
The older I get, the better I was !
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
Usually, when some one thinks or say's 'not really sure' , it can be a call to "bleep"-ure them they are either right for not doing it or wrong for not doing it?Onk wrote: I've never force fetch trained a dog and not really sure if it's the right thing to do. So any advice?
When some one asks after 5 years ,then that there is a 'ding' moment ? ..Shoulda,woulda coulda ?.
Sounds like your main issue is 'Stands over game' ?> rather than retrieve?
FF , (IMO) has nothing to do with either.
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
Sounds like he may have plenty of natural retrieve. I would test him. I'd send him for a retrieve and when he leaves, so would I, in the opposite direction. Say nothing. What he does next will speak volumes.
Brad Higgins
Higgins Gundogs
___________________________
Higgins Gundogs hunting etiquette
Dogs: Stay in touch and handle well. Always honor another dog's point, be steady when necessary and manage the birds for the gun.
Handlers: Be silent in the hunt. Allow the dog the freedom to do his work. Nurture the natural retrieve.
Brad Higgins
Higgins Gundogs
___________________________
Higgins Gundogs hunting etiquette
Dogs: Stay in touch and handle well. Always honor another dog's point, be steady when necessary and manage the birds for the gun.
Handlers: Be silent in the hunt. Allow the dog the freedom to do his work. Nurture the natural retrieve.
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
what is C.T. ?
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
Ask the one who posted
Last edited by polmaise on Sun Sep 27, 2015 4:32 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
As I don't train force fetch the above would be the first thing I'd try too. If it did not work then I'd either try F.F. or C.T. and I'd try C.T. first of those two as there is less that can go badly wrong when done by an inexperienced trainer.Trekmoor wrote:h&t wrote: I'd use jealousy to train fetch - another dog or a person, as you describe.
Bill T.[/quote
this
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
C.T. = Click /treat. A method in which a clicking device operated by the trainer "marks" the correct/wanted behaviour from the dog and the dog is then at once given a "treat." The treat can be food or just about anything else a particular dog really loves . There is a lot more to it than that but I definitely am not a clicker "expert." It isn't a method I use very much but it can cure some bad retrieve problems if done even at my level of incompetence.
The best thing about the method is that if you make a muck-up of training it, very little or no harm is done . The same cannot be said for a badly messed up F.F.
As I said earlier, I would use other methods first .....if jealousy can be called a method. The dog does seem to have a retrieve instinct but it has been allowed to atrophy or become a bit warped over a period of years.
Bill T.
The best thing about the method is that if you make a muck-up of training it, very little or no harm is done . The same cannot be said for a badly messed up F.F.
As I said earlier, I would use other methods first .....if jealousy can be called a method. The dog does seem to have a retrieve instinct but it has been allowed to atrophy or become a bit warped over a period of years.
Bill T.
The older I get, the better I was !
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
I watched some vidios on force fetch, built a table and trained my dog FF after she started not fetching wild birds. Use lots of patience. don't get hard on the dog and you will not screw him up. Work at it day after day until he gives in. My dog fetches perfectly on command and I think we are closer from the experience.
- gonehuntin'
- GDF Junkie
- Posts: 4870
- Joined: Tue Dec 12, 2006 5:38 pm
- Location: NE WI.
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
oldbeek wrote:I watched some vidios on force fetch, built a table and trained my dog FF after she started not fetching wild birds. Use lots of patience. don't get hard on the dog and you will not screw him up. Work at it day after day until he gives in. My dog fetches perfectly on command and I think we are closer from the experience.
Good observation. There is no stronger bond with a dog than after you have ff'd it.
LIFE WITHOUT BIRD DOGS AND FLY RODS REALLY ISN'T LIFE AT ALL.
-
- Rank: 5X Champion
- Posts: 1271
- Joined: Sun Jun 22, 2014 5:10 pm
- Location: Northern Minnesota
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
I would agree. Dogs need structure and consistency. FF, when done correctly, provides both. Lots of people are intimidated by the process, but in my mind it is training 101: teach the dog your expectations and then enforce (reinforce) the rules. If you are unwilling to do so, your dog will never view you as the leader, and will try become the leader himself.gonehuntin' wrote:oldbeek wrote:I watched some vidios on force fetch, built a table and trained my dog FF after she started not fetching wild birds. Use lots of patience. don't get hard on the dog and you will not screw him up. Work at it day after day until he gives in. My dog fetches perfectly on command and I think we are closer from the experience.
Good observation. There is no stronger bond with a dog than after you have ff'd it.
“Man's mind, once stretched by a new idea, never regains its original dimensions.”
― Oliver Wendell Holmes Sr.
― Oliver Wendell Holmes Sr.
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
WRT clicker (CT), I find it's useful for teach a young dog new things, not so much for changing old habits...
-
- Rank: 2X Champion
- Posts: 492
- Joined: Sun Aug 09, 2015 11:30 am
- Location: Missouri
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
The worst dogs I have ever hunted with were not Force Fetched! That includes some flushers, some pointers, and some retrievers.....!
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
I completely agree. But then you know that!gonehuntin' wrote:oldbeek wrote:I watched some vidios on force fetch, built a table and trained my dog FF after she started not fetching wild birds. Use lots of patience. don't get hard on the dog and you will not screw him up. Work at it day after day until he gives in. My dog fetches perfectly on command and I think we are closer from the experience.
Good observation. There is no stronger bond with a dog than after you have ff'd it.
EvanG
“Not all of us can do great things. But we can do small things with great love.”
― Mother Teresa
There is little reason to expect a dog to be more precise than you are.-- Rex Carr
The Smartwork System for Retriever Training (link)
Official Evan Graham Retriever Training Forum
― Mother Teresa
There is little reason to expect a dog to be more precise than you are.-- Rex Carr
The Smartwork System for Retriever Training (link)
Official Evan Graham Retriever Training Forum
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
Just choked on my coffee...Timewise65 wrote:The worst dogs I have ever hunted with were not Force Fetched! That includes some flushers, some pointers, and some retrievers.....!
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
I can't really argue against Timewise's statement because I've never hunted with any dog that had been force fetched.
My only observation is this..... Britain has virtually no F.F. trained gundogs at all including all the F.T.Ch.'s. Timewise's statement could therefor mean that every F.F.'d gundog in America is a better gundog than any British dog. Somehow I doubt if that is true ?
Bill T.
My only observation is this..... Britain has virtually no F.F. trained gundogs at all including all the F.T.Ch.'s. Timewise's statement could therefor mean that every F.F.'d gundog in America is a better gundog than any British dog. Somehow I doubt if that is true ?
Bill T.
The older I get, the better I was !
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
Had one dog that was force fetched from a well known Midwest kennel. Problem was they had to sell herTimewise65 wrote:The worst dogs I have ever hunted with were not Force Fetched! That includes some flushers, some pointers, and some retrievers.....!
because she was scared to death their the trainers. I paid about twice what she was worth to get her out of there. She was a great dog for me and was my foundation female. She did have an awesome retrieve but it was not worth what they did to her.
Could be the worst dog you hunted over were not force fetched but maybe they were just bad dogs....Cj
- gonehuntin'
- GDF Junkie
- Posts: 4870
- Joined: Tue Dec 12, 2006 5:38 pm
- Location: NE WI.
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
Had one dog that was force fetched from a well known Midwest kennel. Problem was they had to sell hercjhills wrote:Timewise65 wrote:The worst dogs I have ever hunted with were not Force Fetched! That includes some flushers, some pointers, and some retrievers.....!
because she was scared to death their the trainers. I paid about twice what she was worth to get her out of there. She was a great dog for me and was my foundation female. She did have an awesome retrieve but it was not worth what they did to her.
Could be the worst dog you hunted over were not force fetched but maybe they were just bad dogs....Cj[/
If a dog is cowed after going through ff, it is a problem with the trainer, not with the principle. A dog can be brutalized at any time during training by a bad trainer. It is not a fault of the program.
Are dog's as happy when ff is completed as when it was started? Absolutely not, but they will be in a week or two, they'll be trained, and the'll have a stronger bond with the trainer than before it started. Dog's don't have to always be happy during training. Some dog's are a-holes just like some people and their attitude is reflected in their training, it is not a reflection OF the training.
LIFE WITHOUT BIRD DOGS AND FLY RODS REALLY ISN'T LIFE AT ALL.
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
To bring up a variant of all of this, my setter's just 10 months old and I've released pigeons and done obedience work. I'm planning on just seeing how this first season goes and then adjusting his training regimen to suit what needs he presents.
In any case, do you all agree that should I need to FF, it should happen perhaps next summer when he's 1 1/2? 10 months is definitely too early, no?
In any case, do you all agree that should I need to FF, it should happen perhaps next summer when he's 1 1/2? 10 months is definitely too early, no?
- gonehuntin'
- GDF Junkie
- Posts: 4870
- Joined: Tue Dec 12, 2006 5:38 pm
- Location: NE WI.
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
Ten months is not to early to start IF he's had a ton of bird contacts. If not, hunt him for a year. A year and a half is actually a great age to ff him.
LIFE WITHOUT BIRD DOGS AND FLY RODS REALLY ISN'T LIFE AT ALL.
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
The worst dogs I have ever hunted with were ones that were not trained! That also includes many flusher's,many pointers,and many retrievers.....!Timewise65 wrote:The worst dogs I have ever hunted with were not Force Fetched! That includes some flushers, some pointers, and some retrievers.....!
Almost all of them could flush,or Point,or Retrieve! ..But those skills were already in the individual dogs . The rest of the stuff that is required when hunting with us mere humans requires training no matter what camp you follow.
I tend not to hunt with these ones that have no training.
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
That's what I'm thinking. Seems like a dog needs a certain level of maturity so that it doesn't confuse potentially unpleasant stimulation/correction with hunting and birds.gonehuntin' wrote:Ten months is not to early to start IF he's had a ton of bird contacts. If not, hunt him for a year. A year and a half is actually a great age to ff him.
- gonehuntin'
- GDF Junkie
- Posts: 4870
- Joined: Tue Dec 12, 2006 5:38 pm
- Location: NE WI.
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
All dog's are different. Some can go through ff at six months, some not. It always seemed to me that the older a dog became (to a point) the easier the accepted ff. They accepted the pressure better and in a more mature manner.
LIFE WITHOUT BIRD DOGS AND FLY RODS REALLY ISN'T LIFE AT ALL.
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
Pretty much ?...But the dog has to know how to and love retrieving first .NEhomer wrote: Seems like a dog needs a certain level of maturity so that it doesn't confuse potentially unpleasant stimulation/correction with hunting and birds.
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
IMO there is no need to FF PROVIDED you start at "play fetch " with a 8 week old pup
Heck in my early 20 "s had 2 Dobermans , as a party trick I trained them to fetch my smokes, matches and car keys from the dinning room table
Having nothing against FF I used it myself on my latest pointer because I got him at just under 12 months old and he never was given the opportunity to learn to retrieve as a pup from the previous owner
Heck in my early 20 "s had 2 Dobermans , as a party trick I trained them to fetch my smokes, matches and car keys from the dinning room table
Having nothing against FF I used it myself on my latest pointer because I got him at just under 12 months old and he never was given the opportunity to learn to retrieve as a pup from the previous owner
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
I followed Evan Graham's Smart Fetch method on my dog. I found that applying more pressure did not make him comply so I backed off because I didn't want him to start "clamming". Evan mentions this in his video but just says "Don't try to defeat your dog by applying more pressure as that can lead to clamming issues which we won't go into here"... I wasn't sure what to do so I just kept applying an even amount of pressure and made the dog pick up the bumper by forcing his head down to it and pushing the bumper/paint roll into his mouth. We got past that and he knew what he was supposed to do.
From that point it was just more and more practice.
My dog isn't perfect as he will still bite down on the bird too hard but he does not sit and try to eat it like he used to do...
The folks at Perfection Kennel are coming out with a retrieve training DVD "soon" (was supposed to be August 1st but they're still in the final stages of editing). I really like their Perfect Start / Finish DVDs so I'm excited about their retrieve training and I plan to buy that to see if I can use that to clean up some of my dog's issues. In their other training methods, they apply as little pressure as possible to the dogs and they show multiple dogs going through the various broken down steps of training so I expect the same very thorough work out of this DVD. Hopefully they finish it soon but if you're worried about the force aspect, I suspect their methods may be better for you. (I'm just guessing here based on their other videos since it isn't out yet, obviously)
http://www.perfectionkennel.com/
From that point it was just more and more practice.
My dog isn't perfect as he will still bite down on the bird too hard but he does not sit and try to eat it like he used to do...
The folks at Perfection Kennel are coming out with a retrieve training DVD "soon" (was supposed to be August 1st but they're still in the final stages of editing). I really like their Perfect Start / Finish DVDs so I'm excited about their retrieve training and I plan to buy that to see if I can use that to clean up some of my dog's issues. In their other training methods, they apply as little pressure as possible to the dogs and they show multiple dogs going through the various broken down steps of training so I expect the same very thorough work out of this DVD. Hopefully they finish it soon but if you're worried about the force aspect, I suspect their methods may be better for you. (I'm just guessing here based on their other videos since it isn't out yet, obviously)
http://www.perfectionkennel.com/
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
Enlighten me ?> What part of this was to do with FF that Evan or anyone of repute advocated in the process.skunk wrote: My dog isn't perfect as he will still bite down on the bird too hard but he does not sit and try to eat it like he used to do...
- gonehuntin'
- GDF Junkie
- Posts: 4870
- Joined: Tue Dec 12, 2006 5:38 pm
- Location: NE WI.
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
From my aspect, an important aspect of ff is that it controls movement of the jaws and teaches a dog to keep his head up. Works with some hard mouth dog's, not others. I don't believe there's a trainer in the world that can cure a truly hard mouth dog. Nor a system, other than a bullet to the head.
LIFE WITHOUT BIRD DOGS AND FLY RODS REALLY ISN'T LIFE AT ALL.
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
I have read several times now that teaching an F.F.'d retrieve can cure hard mouth. I wouldn't know since I don't teach F.F., I have heard or read of other "cures" too but I don't think there is a dead cert cure.....other than a bullet to the head.
Hard mouth seems to come in too many different forms for any one training method that can cure all of them. There are dogs that only bite down on the first bird they get during a hunt. There are dogs that only bite down on strong runners. There are dogs that bite down hard enough to squeeze a birds guts out and there are dogs that don't appear to be putting any pressure on birds but whose birds have their ribs caved in just the same !
I cannot see F.F. being any more successful than any other method for curing any and all of the several variations of hard mouth.
Bill T.
Hard mouth seems to come in too many different forms for any one training method that can cure all of them. There are dogs that only bite down on the first bird they get during a hunt. There are dogs that only bite down on strong runners. There are dogs that bite down hard enough to squeeze a birds guts out and there are dogs that don't appear to be putting any pressure on birds but whose birds have their ribs caved in just the same !
I cannot see F.F. being any more successful than any other method for curing any and all of the several variations of hard mouth.
Bill T.
The older I get, the better I was !
- gonehuntin'
- GDF Junkie
- Posts: 4870
- Joined: Tue Dec 12, 2006 5:38 pm
- Location: NE WI.
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
I would agree with that Bill. To me, I don't consider a dog killing a bird a fault, as long as the bird is still fit for the table.
LIFE WITHOUT BIRD DOGS AND FLY RODS REALLY ISN'T LIFE AT ALL.
-
- Rank: 2X Champion
- Posts: 492
- Joined: Sun Aug 09, 2015 11:30 am
- Location: Missouri
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
I can see that many are confused or have information that is inconsistent with most FF training. Since a couple of you have mentioned Evan Graham, I will quote from his SMARTWORKS for Retrievers, Volume one, Basics and Transition, Chapter 6, page 47
"Force Fetching -- This is the core of the system"
"Force fetching is not an option to use when a mouth problem has come up. It is a fundamental component of this system. Regardless of how maniacal your dog is for birds, this procedure is a must. It will ensure the proper delivery of birds to hand. And is the nucleus of active momentum by way of providing a positive mechanism of compulsion."
Over my lifetime I have seen many field dogs who are either hard mouthed and/or do not deliver to hand! Most of the time I was able to confirm that these dogs were not FF. I also have hunted with some fine dogs that are soft mouthed and do deliver to hand that were not FF. So I know in some cases it can be done, but I believe it take a very experienced trainer to first recognize the dog as a dog that does not need to be FF, and secondarily being able to provide alternate training techniques to accomplish the desired outcome on that particular dog.
In general, properly done, FF will dramatically increase the odds of having a dog that will deliver to hand and be soft mouthed.
And of course, these dogs must also be thoroughly trained gun dogs in obedience and basic field training....that goes without saying!
"Force Fetching -- This is the core of the system"
"Force fetching is not an option to use when a mouth problem has come up. It is a fundamental component of this system. Regardless of how maniacal your dog is for birds, this procedure is a must. It will ensure the proper delivery of birds to hand. And is the nucleus of active momentum by way of providing a positive mechanism of compulsion."
Over my lifetime I have seen many field dogs who are either hard mouthed and/or do not deliver to hand! Most of the time I was able to confirm that these dogs were not FF. I also have hunted with some fine dogs that are soft mouthed and do deliver to hand that were not FF. So I know in some cases it can be done, but I believe it take a very experienced trainer to first recognize the dog as a dog that does not need to be FF, and secondarily being able to provide alternate training techniques to accomplish the desired outcome on that particular dog.
In general, properly done, FF will dramatically increase the odds of having a dog that will deliver to hand and be soft mouthed.
And of course, these dogs must also be thoroughly trained gun dogs in obedience and basic field training....that goes without saying!
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
I'm not sure I understand what you're asking or getting at. Before I force fetched my dog, he would try to keep the bird for himself. Now that I have taken him through the process, he doesn't do that as he must bring the bird back to me. The problem I still have is he will still bite down hard on the bird when he does pick it up.polmaise wrote:Enlighten me ?> What part of this was to do with FF that Evan or anyone of repute advocated in the process.skunk wrote: My dog isn't perfect as he will still bite down on the bird too hard but he does not sit and try to eat it like he used to do...
I don't want to make this post about my dog so I'll leave it at that.
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
I'll leave it here 'Skunk' .Timewise65 wrote: And of course, these dogs must also be thoroughly trained gun dogs in obedience and basic field training....that goes without saying!
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
the only ones I know that can cure "hard mouth" are the breeders
-
- Rank: Junior Hunter
- Posts: 89
- Joined: Sat Dec 22, 2012 2:56 am
- Location: Central Ohio
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
Did you teach your dog to sit? Come on command? If your expectation is a reliable retrieve then it needs to be taught. The use force or some other method, that is your choice and somewhat depends on the dog's temperament. I follow SmartFetch program for my Spinoni. Not a fan of the wording "force fetch". We don't say force sit, force recall. I prefer to think of it as trained retrieve.
- gonehuntin'
- GDF Junkie
- Posts: 4870
- Joined: Tue Dec 12, 2006 5:38 pm
- Location: NE WI.
Re: To Force Fetch or Not to Force Fetch?
You can prefer that term, but when a dog quits retrieving, you force it to. For the amateur, your method is fine. Most pro's today still FORCE the dog to retrieve.BellaSpinone wrote:Did you teach your dog to sit? Come on command? If your expectation is a reliable retrieve then it needs to be taught. The use force or some other method, that is your choice and somewhat depends on the dog's temperament. I follow SmartFetch program for my Spinoni. Not a fan of the wording "force fetch". We don't say force sit, force recall. I prefer to think of it as trained retrieve.
LIFE WITHOUT BIRD DOGS AND FLY RODS REALLY ISN'T LIFE AT ALL.